Brown Sugar Blueberry Pie Shakes

Brown Sugar Blueberry Pie Shakes — as indulgent as they sound, all the flavor of blueberry pie in a creamy dreamy blueberry milkshake whirled with nutty almond butter and studded with shortbread cookies. Yes please.

Brown Sugar Blueberry Pie Shakes recipe (via #milkshake #icecream #summer #drinkthesummer
This past weekend was full of firsts. My first real vacay away from the babe. My first show at Red Rocks. My first exposure to Dr. Pimple Popper. (I can get into a lot of bizarre shit, but I just can’t do it, you guys.)

The four days I spent in Denver were so very indulgent. Leisurely breakfasts in with old friends. Leisurely breakfasts out with new friends. Pedicures. Sour beers. Reclining movie theater seats. Wait — backtrack. MOVIES IN A MOVIE THEATER?? BE STILL MY HEART. ♥

Daily hair washing. Rootbeer milk. Driving stick shift. Caffeine.

Is this real life? I kept asking myself.
Nay, this how the childless live, a little voice answered.

Oh. Huh. I had completely forgotten.

So what makes it a Blueberry Pie Shake?

Let me tell you: these pie shakes — PIE SHAKES!!! — are a continuation of this weekend’s indulgence. They won’t win any clean eating awards, but in the name of living a little, I’m gonna ask you to just roll with it.

Summery blueberries.
Nutty brown sugar.
Real ice cream.
A one-two punch of almond butter and shortbread cookies that, together, simulate the richness of pie crust.

I’m not going to try much harder than that to sell you on these things, because when it comes down to it, you’re either a pie shake person or you’re not. Put another way: you’re either my friend, or you’re not.

Just kidding: I have no fraaaannds.

Brown Sugar Blueberry Pie Shakes recipe (via #milkshake #icecream #summer #drinkthesummer
Many hugs to Chris and Momma Stoffel for showing our babe such a good time while I was off galavanting at high altitude these past few days. That little bug’s complete apathy at my return is nothing if not a testament to your superior caregiving skills. Or my stale airplane hair. What I’m tryna say is: I’d pay cash money for that sweet bugaboo to squeeze me.

You hear that, baby girl? HUG YER MOMMA.
There’s a pie shake in it for you.

p.s. Tremendous thanks to Sherrie (With Food + Love) for hosting today’s #DrinkTheSummer virtual shindig, which (in addition to my own gluttony) was the catalyst for these summery sippables. Be sure to scroll down to check out the other 50+ bloggers cheersing the season with their best drinkalinks, below. Yay!
p.p.s. That time I made pumpkin pie shakes, too!

With Food + Love | Basil Fig Vodka Smash
A Little Saffron | Beach Bum’s Rum
A Thought For Food | Tarragon Tequlia Swizzle
Heart of a Baker | Green Tea Mint Cooler
Hungry Girl por Vida | Whisky Peach Alexander
Beard and Bonnet | Melon Mojito
Appeasing a Food Geek | Basil and Black Pepper Gin Sour
Vegetarian Ventures | Garden Tonic Punch
The Foodie Nurse | Husk Cherry Margarita
Wicked Spatula | Coconut Gin and Tonic
Nutritionist in the Kitch | Healthy Muddled Blackberry Pina Coladas
Chocolate + Marrow | Pequito Verdecito
The Solstice Table | Jalapeno Watermelon Cooler
Seasonal Cravings | Strawberry Lime Gin Rickey
Dessert for Two | Salty Melon Slush
Heartbeet Kitchen | Salty Watermelon Shrub Elixir
My Heart Beets | Spiced Pistachio Shake
rooting the sun | Strawberry Fennel Soda
The Modern Proper | Vanilla Plum Shrub
Gourmande in the Kitchen | Stone Fruit Thyme Shrub Soda
I am a Food Blog | Cherry Vanilla Sodas
Well and Full | Peach Bubble Tea
Like the sound of these Brown Sugar Blueberry Pie Shakes?

Be sure to check out:

Brown Sugar Blueberry Pie Shakes recipe (via #milkshake #icecream #summer #drinkthesummer
Brown Sugar Blueberry Pie Shakes recipe (via #milkshake #icecream #summer #drinkthesummer
Brown Sugar Blueberry Pie Shakes recipe (via #milkshake #icecream #summer #drinkthesummer
Brown Sugar Blueberry Pie Shakes recipe (via #milkshake #icecream #summer #drinkthesummer
Brown Sugar Blueberry Pie Shakes recipe (via #milkshake #icecream #summer #drinkthesummer
Brown Sugar Blueberry Pie Shakes recipe (via #milkshake #icecream #summer #drinkthesummer
Brown Sugar Blueberry Pie Shakes
Prep time
Total time
Brown Sugar Blueberry Pie Shakes -- as indulgent as they sound, all the flavor of blueberry pie in a creamy dreamy blueberry milkshake whirled with nutty almond butter and studded with shortbread cookies. Yes please.
Makes: 2 servings
  • 1 cup vanilla ice cream, plus extra for topping
  • 1 cup frozen blueberries, plus extra for topping
  • 4 shortbread cookies, plus extra for topping
  • 2 T almond butter
  • 2 heaping T brown sugar, plus extra for topping
  • ¼ tsp cinnamon
  • pinch salt
  • 1.5 cups milk or almond milk
  1. Combine all ingredients in a high-powered blender in the order listed and blend until smooth. Divide between two glasses.
  2. Top each glass with an additional scoop of ice cream, a handful of blueberries, a shortbread cookie and a generous sprinkling of brown sugar. Enjoy!
Brown Sugar Blueberry Pie Shakes recipe (via #milkshake #icecream #summer #drinkthesummer————————————————–

OH! before you go…

Like whatcha see here — or have a question, feedback, or recipe hack to share? Join The Pig & Quill convo by commenting below (I love, luv, lurve comments) and hang out with me on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram and Pinterest. And don’t forget to subscribe to P&Q emails or add me to your RSS reader with Feedly or Bloglovin’ so you never miss a post. x’s & o’s!

Gingered Mint Tea Sparkler // Happy Bday P&Q!
Gazpacho Andaluz with Smoked Paprika-Glazed Almonds

16 Comments on “Brown Sugar Blueberry Pie Shakes”

  1. Holy moly that color. And the fact that it’s a pie shake. LOVE.
    I’ve never been to Denver but I was a-creepin’ on your Instagram and it looks so fun! On my travel list. Will hopefully go this year!

    1. It was SO fun, Erica — and we didn’t do half of what we could’ve done in the area. (Essentially we just ate and drank, and even with four days in town we still barely put a dent in our belly list.) And YES – that color! Anything THAT purple is basically a superfood, right? Thought so! 😀

  2. who needs clean eating awards?! the almond butter should count for something, anyways. and lol: check out “please come home for christimas.” the timing is a little awkward, but you might appreciate the lyrics (and it was really fun to sing when i was in choir).

    1. Ah yes, “my baby’s gone I have no friends.” What if my baby is my ONLY friend? Is that better or worse? 😉 And YES to calling out that almond butter as health food. It makes it all better to slurp this down for two “meals” in a row!

  3. Killin it as usual! These shakes look spectacular.

    Btw, if you’re ever in Iowa City, you need to stop at the Hamburg Inn diner and get a pie milkshake.

    1. Thanks girl – yep, shortbread cookies on the shakes, shortbread cookies IN the shakes! Hard to go wrong! 😀

  4. Girl, I loooooooove these so much. I just want you to come back to Denver and make some for me. Because LAZY. Right now, all I want to do is catch up on sleep and watch Netflix. That’s okay because seasons do change. I’m looking forward to renewed autumnal-driven energy. You brought some cooler air here, when you visited, for sure. I’m not complaining!!

    I’ll say it again – it was SO, SO nice meeting you and enjoying brunch at my fave spot in Denver. I’m smiling as I type this – it felt like we were old friends from high school, catching up after ten or so years. Much love your way, Em!! XOXOXOXO!!

    1. So sweet, Jayme. We had the loveliest time, too, and I’m so glad we got to get out of the city center a bit to explore at your urging. Such a fun weekend, and Amanda and I both agreed that Devil’s Food was one of the most memorable meals (given both the food AND company, of course!). And old friends from high school is such a perfect way to describe our (long-awaited) get together. Let’s not let another “10 years” pass us by! 😀

  5. Ooooh girl. These are over the top and I freaking love it. Also love you experienced Red Rocks. Isn’t it the most amazing place ever? Love you! Love this contribution to #DRINKTHESUMMER 2016, xx!!

    1. Ohhh man Red Rocks was AMAY.ZING. Sherrie! I don’t know what I was expecting. I mean, I guess I had pictured the amphitheater accurately but for some reason I had no idea how high it was set over the surrounding landscape and skyline. It knocked my socks off. And I’ll toast summer with you anytime, girl! Hopefully even IRL one of these days. 🙂 CHEERS!

Leave a Reply